Movie review: The Tell-Tale Heart (1960)

Andrew McCaffrey
4 min readOct 28, 2023

It must be an ambitious undertaking for a film production to tackle Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Tell-Tale Heart”. After all, it is one of Poe’s most famous and chilling works. If the film falls flat on its face, then the director can’t simply blame the original text for being underwhelming. And much of the horror is based upon Poe’s prose which is not the easiest thing to convey in film.

Movie post for The Tell-Tale Heart (1960)

However, the most challenging aspect must be the fact that Poe’s original story is a little more than five pages long. It works as one quick effective jolt, not as a long sustaining opus. While The Internet Movie Database lists an astonishing 22 attempts at filming this story, I was hesitant to see how this particular instantiation (a low-budget 1960 British full length film) would attempt to pad the length.

Writing additional material into Poe’s classic work is something that should only be attempted by experts. Surprisingly, there was a writing team up to the challenge. The most famous of this pair is Brian Clemens who is now more known for having written for and having produced The Avengers, The Professionals and other British television programs. At this point in his career, he was churning out a lot of B-movie crime/thriller scripts with his writing partner Eldon Howard.

--

--

Andrew McCaffrey
Andrew McCaffrey

Written by Andrew McCaffrey

I can be reached at amccaf1@gmail.com. If you would like a "friends link" to bypass any pay-walled story, please drop me a line.